The short answer

Choose a cabinet pantry with pull-outs when space is tight, a reach-in pantry when you have a closet next to the kitchen, a walk-in pantry when you have a small room to give it, and a butler’s pantry when you want a second work area for serving, coffee or small appliances. In every case, keep shelves shallow enough to see everything, put daily items between hip and shoulder height and plan lighting from the start.

What types of pantry are there?

Four types of pantry compared
TypeSpace neededBest forPlan for
Cabinet pantryA tall cabinet or two in the kitchen runKitchens without a spare closetFull-extension pull-outs or inner drawers, so nothing hides at the back
Reach-in pantryA shallow closet beside the kitchenMost new-construction kitchensShelves on the back wall and narrow shelves on the side walls, plus door storage
Walk-in pantryA small roomBulk shopping, large families, entertainingU- or L-shaped shelving, a counter for unpacking groceries, lighting
Butler’s pantryA passage or room between kitchen and diningServing, coffee, wine, small appliancesBase and wall cabinets, a counter, outlets and possibly a sink or beverage fridge

Where should the pantry go?

As close to where you unpack groceries and prepare food as the plan allows. A pantry at the far end of the house turns every meal into a walk. In most kitchens the best spots are beside the refrigerator, at the end of a cabinet run, or in a closet that opens from the kitchen itself.

Think about the route from the garage, too. In many Central Florida homes, groceries come in through the garage and the laundry room. If the pantry sits on that path, unloading becomes one trip. If the kitchen has no room for a separate pantry, a run of tall cabinets with pull-outs along one wall can do the same job without taking a door away from the plan.

Finally, check the doors. A walk-in pantry door that swings into the kitchen can block a drawer or an appliance; a pocket door or a door that opens into the pantry often works better.

How deep should pantry shelves be?

Shallower than most people expect. Deep shelves look generous but turn into stacks where the back row disappears. For cans, jars and boxes, shelves that hold one or two items deep keep everything visible. Deeper shelves, or deep drawers, are better for bulk packs, small appliances and baskets.

Adjustable shelves are worth it. What you store changes, and being able to move a shelf an inch or two keeps tall bottles and cereal boxes from wasting the space above shorter items.

Drawers, pull-outs or shelves?

  • Shelves are the most flexible and the easiest to see in a walk-in or reach-in pantry.
  • Drawers work best low down, for heavy items, potatoes and onions, pet food and bulk packs, so you are not kneeling to reach the back.
  • Full-height pull-outs turn a narrow, deep cabinet into storage you can see from both sides in one motion.
  • Inner drawers behind a door combine a clean tall front with drawers inside, a good fit for cabinet pantries in modern kitchens.
  • Door racks in a reach-in pantry hold spices and small jars that get lost on shelves.
Lit pantry niche with black mesh fruit baskets set into wood cabinetry

How do you organize a pantry so it stays organized?

Zone it the way you cook. Breakfast items together, baking together, snacks at a height children can reach if you want them to, and backup stock above or below everyday items. Keep the zone you use most between hip and shoulder height, closest to the door.

Lighting does more than anything else to keep a pantry usable. A light that turns on when the door opens, or LED strips along the shelves, means you see the back of every shelf without moving things.

What makes a butler’s pantry different?

A butler’s pantry is a work area, not just storage. It usually sits between the kitchen and the dining room and holds glassware, serving pieces and a counter for preparing drinks or plating. Many include a coffee station, a wine or beverage fridge, and sometimes a small sink.

That makes it more of a kitchen project. Outlets for appliances, a beverage fridge or a sink connection involve electrical or plumbing work, which usually needs a permit. Our guide to permits for cabinet projects in Orlando explains what to check. If your butler’s pantry leans toward wine and entertaining, browse bar and wine cabinetry for ideas.

What does a custom pantry cost?

It depends on the type of pantry, its size, the mix of shelves, drawers and pull-outs, lighting, and whether the project includes counters, appliances or plumbing. A reach-in pantry with shelving is a smaller project than a butler’s pantry with base cabinets, a counter and a beverage fridge. Pricing is based on the design and discussed in the design consultation.

A pantry is often designed together with the kitchen, so the fronts, finishes and handles match. See custom kitchens for ideas.

How Novelli designs a pantry

We start with what you store and how often you reach for it, then design the pantry together with the kitchen, so fronts, finishes and lighting match. A hidden pantry behind full-height doors is one of the details frameless construction does well.

  • See it before you decide. We measure your room and present the design in 3D.
  • Frameless, European-style construction. Full-overlay fronts, concealed hinges and full-extension drawers in every room we design.
  • Made by a manufacturing partner founded in 1976. Panels cut on CNC machines from your approved design, with edge banding applied before assembly.
  • Delivery in about 60 days from approval, with installation scheduled after delivery and a 5-year extended warranty*.

*Covers installation and TFL and MDF panels. Ask your designer to see the written warranty.

Frequently asked questions

Is a walk-in pantry worth it?

If you buy in bulk, cook often or entertain, a walk-in pantry frees the kitchen cabinets for cookware and daily use. If space is limited, a well-planned cabinet or reach-in pantry can hold a surprising amount.

What is the difference between a butler’s pantry and a scullery?

A butler’s pantry is mainly for serving and storage between kitchen and dining room. A scullery, sometimes called a working pantry, is a back kitchen for messy prep and cleanup, usually with a sink and dishwasher.

Can I convert a coat closet into a pantry?

Often, yes, if the closet is near the kitchen. Replacing the rod and shelf with shallow, adjustable shelves and door storage turns it into a reach-in pantry.

Should pantry shelves be adjustable?

Yes. Adjustable shelves let you change spacing as what you store changes, and avoid wasted height above short items.

Do I need a permit to build a butler’s pantry?

Cabinets alone in the same location often do not, but adding outlets, a sink or a beverage fridge circuit usually involves permitted electrical or plumbing work. Check with your city or county building department.